When an E-Verify case comes back with a Tentative Nonconfirmation, or TNC (shown in E-Verify as a mismatch), many HR teams feel a jolt of worry. It sounds like a problem with the employee. In reality, a TNC simply means the information entered in E-Verify did not match records at the Social Security Administration (SSA) or the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). It is not a finding that the person is unauthorized to work.
How you handle a TNC matters. The rules protect employees from being treated unfairly while a mismatch is resolved, and mistakes here can create discrimination exposure that is far more serious than the mismatch itself. Here are the practical do's and don'ts.
What a TNC actually means
A mismatch can happen for many ordinary reasons. A name changed after marriage or divorce and was never updated with SSA. A typo crept into the case when it was created. A recent change in immigration status has not yet been reflected in government records. Hyphenated or multi-part names were entered differently in different systems.
None of these mean the employee did anything wrong. The TNC process exists to give the employee a fair chance to correct the record. Your role as the employer is to follow the steps, communicate clearly and stay neutral.
Do: check your own data entry first
Before you notify the employee, compare the information in the E-Verify case with the employee's Form I-9 and the documents they presented. If the mismatch came from a data entry error on your side, such as a transposed digit in a Social Security number or a misspelled name, the right move is to close the case as created in error and create a new, accurate one, following E-Verify's instructions.
This simple check prevents unnecessary stress for the employee and keeps your records clean.
Do: notify the employee promptly and privately
If the data is correct, you must notify the employee of the TNC. E-Verify generates a Further Action Notice that explains the mismatch and the employee's options. Review it with the employee in a private setting, not in front of coworkers or a supervisor who does not need to be involved.
Give the employee the Further Action Notice in a language they understand when E-Verify offers one. The employee then decides whether to take action to resolve the mismatch, and that decision is recorded in E-Verify. Keep a copy of the signed notice with the employee's Form I-9 or in your E-Verify records, as E-Verify directs.
Do: let the employee decide whether to take action
Whether to take action on a TNC is the employee's choice. Do not pressure them either way, and do not suggest that taking action will cause problems for them. If they choose to take action, you refer the case in E-Verify. The employee then has eight federal government working days from the referral to contact SSA or visit or contact DHS, depending on which agency issued the mismatch.
Give the employee the referral information E-Verify provides, and allow reasonable time during work hours to resolve it if they need it, consistent with how you treat other employees.
Don't: take adverse action while the case is open
This is the most important rule. While a TNC is pending, you may not take any adverse action against the employee because of the mismatch. That includes:
- Terminating or suspending the employee
- Delaying their start date or training
- Reducing hours or pay
- Withholding work assignments
- Requiring them to produce new or additional documents
The employee should keep working normally while the case moves forward. If the case stays open longer than expected, that does not change the rule. E-Verify may place a case in continuance while an agency needs more time, and the protections still apply.
Don't: ask for more documents
A TNC is resolved between the employee and SSA or DHS. It is not resolved by the employer asking for different or additional Form I-9 documents. Requesting more paperwork because of a mismatch can look like document abuse and is exactly the kind of practice that draws discrimination complaints.
If the employee brings new information, such as an updated Social Security record, follow E-Verify's instructions for that step rather than redoing the Form I-9.
Don't: use E-Verify selectively or to prescreen
E-Verify cases are created only after a person has accepted a job offer and completed Form I-9. You may not run applicants through E-Verify before an offer, and you may not choose which new hires to verify based on citizenship, national origin, accent or appearance. Use it consistently for every new hire at sites that participate.
These practices are not only E-Verify rule violations. They can also be treated as unfair immigration-related employment practices.
What happens next
Once the employee contacts the right agency, the case updates in E-Verify. Most often, the record is corrected and the case moves to Employment Authorized, and you close it.
If the employee chooses not to take action, or does not resolve the mismatch in time, the case can become a Final Nonconfirmation. At that point, you may terminate employment based on the result. If you decide to keep the employee on, E-Verify requires you to tell it you are doing so, and you accept the related risk. Close every case in E-Verify with the result that reflects what happened.
Build a simple TNC playbook
TNCs are uncommon enough that people forget the steps between cases, and common enough that every HR team will see them. A short written playbook helps:
- Confirm the case data matches the Form I-9.
- Notify the employee privately and provide the Further Action Notice.
- Record the employee's decision and refer the case if they take action.
- Keep the employee working with no adverse action.
- Monitor the case and close it with the correct result.
- Store the notice and case details with your I-9 records.
Train everyone who creates E-Verify cases on this sequence, and make sure supervisors know not to change an employee's schedule or duties because of a pending case.
Handle mismatches with confidence
A TNC is a process, not a verdict. Employers who check their own data, communicate clearly and keep hands off employment decisions while a case is open protect both their people and their company. Clear I-9 by TRAK helps teams keep Form I-9 data accurate from the start, which reduces avoidable mismatches, and keeps your verification records organized when a case needs follow-up.
Want fewer surprises in your I-9 and E-Verify process? Request a demo of Clear I-9 and see how it works.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. For guidance on your specific situation, consult qualified employment counsel and the official USCIS resources.