← All articles

Resources

Receipts in Form I-9 Verification: When They Are Acceptable

Most of the time, a new hire hands over an unexpired document from the Lists of Acceptable Documents and Section 2 is straightforward. Every so often, though, the employee says their card was lost, stolen or damaged, or they have just arrived in the United States and their permanent documents have not come yet. In those cases, the employee may present a receipt instead of the document itself.

Receipts are allowed, but only in narrow circumstances and only for a limited period. Accepting the wrong kind of receipt, or forgetting to collect the real document later, is an easy way to end up with a technical violation. This article walks through what counts as an acceptable receipt, how long each one lasts and how to manage the follow-up.

What a receipt means for Form I-9

In I-9 terms, a receipt is temporary proof that the employee has, or is about to have, an acceptable document. It is not a separate category of acceptable documents. The receipt holds the place of a specific List A, List B or List C document until the employee presents the actual document, by a deadline set by the rules.

Because a receipt is a placeholder, the employer has two jobs. First, decide whether what the employee presented is truly one of the acceptable receipt types. Second, track the deadline and complete the follow-up on time.

The three acceptable receipt types

The Form I-9 instructions recognize three kinds of receipts.

1. A receipt for an application to replace a lost, stolen or damaged document. If an employee's acceptable document was lost, stolen or damaged, they can present a receipt showing they applied for a replacement. This works for List A, List B or List C documents. For example, an employee whose driver's license was stolen might present the state's receipt for a replacement license as their List B document.

  • How long it is valid: 90 days from the date of hire (or, for reverification, from the date employment authorization expires).
  • What the employee must present by the deadline: the replacement document itself.

2. Form I-94 or I-94A with a temporary I-551 stamp or a printed notation on a machine-readable immigrant visa (MRIV). This is the arrival record or immigrant visa that a new lawful permanent resident receives before their Permanent Resident Card (Form I-551) arrives. It serves as a List A receipt.

  • How long it is valid: until the expiration date on the temporary I-551 stamp, or, if there is no expiration date, one year from the date of admission.
  • What the employee must present by the deadline: the Permanent Resident Card.

3. Form I-94 or I-94A with an unexpired refugee admission stamp or computer-generated refugee notation. Refugees are authorized to work because of their status, but they often do not yet have an Employment Authorization Document when they start a job. This arrival record serves as a List A receipt.

  • How long it is valid: 90 days from the date of hire.
  • What the employee must present by the deadline: either an Employment Authorization Document (Form I-766), or a List B identity document together with an unrestricted Social Security card from List C.

Notice that the follow-up document for the refugee receipt gives the employee a choice. As with any I-9 document, the employee decides which acceptable documents to present, and the employer should not insist on one option over the other.

What is not an acceptable receipt

Some paperwork looks official but does not qualify as a receipt for I-9 purposes. The most common example is a receipt showing that the employee applied for an initial grant or a renewal of employment authorization. A receipt for a first-time EAD application, or for an EAD renewal, is not an acceptable receipt on its own.

There is a related situation that sometimes causes confusion. Certain employees who filed to renew their EAD on time may qualify for an automatic extension of their expired card. In those cases, the expired EAD combined with the qualifying Form I-797C notice is treated as an unexpired List A document under the extension rules, not as a receipt. The rules and eligible categories for these extensions have changed over time, so it is worth checking current USCIS guidance before accepting this combination.

A few other limits to keep in mind:

  • Short-term jobs: receipts are not acceptable if the employment will last fewer than three business days.
  • Unrelated paperwork: a mailing confirmation, a screenshot of an online form or a letter that does not tie to one of the three receipt types above is not a substitute for an acceptable document.

How to record a receipt in Section 2

When an employee presents an acceptable receipt, record it in Section 2 the way you would record the document it stands for, and note that it is a receipt. For example, enter the document title followed by "Receipt," and use the receipt's number where a document number would go. Many employers also add a note in the Additional Information field showing the date the follow-up document is due.

When the employee later presents the actual document, update the form. The usual practice is to draw a line through the receipt information, write in the new document's details, and initial and date the change. Keep a copy of the new document if your organization copies documents, and apply that copying practice consistently to every employee.

Tracking the deadline is where problems start

Accepting a valid receipt is usually not the hard part. The trouble comes 60 or 90 days later, when nobody remembers the form is incomplete. A receipt that never gets replaced leaves the Form I-9 incomplete, which is the kind of gap that shows up during an internal audit or a government inspection.

A simple process prevents most of this:

  • Log every receipt in one place, with the employee's name, the receipt type and the due date.
  • Set reminders well before the deadline, so the employee has time to bring in the replacement or new document.
  • Assign an owner for each follow-up, especially at companies that hire across several locations.
  • Treat everyone the same. Use the same reminders and the same steps for every employee who presents a receipt, regardless of citizenship status or national origin.

If an employee does not present the required document by the deadline, talk with counsel or your HR compliance lead about next steps rather than improvising.

A note on E-Verify

If your organization participates in E-Verify, receipts add another step. E-Verify has its own instructions for when and how to create a case when an employee presents a receipt, which differ depending on the type of receipt. Check the current E-Verify user manual so the case timing matches the documents on file.

How Clear I-9 helps

Clear I-9 by TRAK keeps receipt follow-ups from slipping through the cracks. Workflows, reporting and tracking show which forms are waiting on a replacement document and when each one is due, so your team can follow up before the deadline instead of after it. Secure document imaging stores the receipt and the follow-up document with the right form, and instant E-Verify keeps case creation in the same workflow. Built-in guidance helps completers choose the right entries in Section 2, so receipts are recorded the same way every time.

Want to see how Clear I-9 tracks receipts and follow-up documents? Request a demo of Clear I-9 and we'll walk you through it.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. For guidance on your specific situation, consult qualified employment counsel and the official USCIS resources.

Book a demo

See Clear I-9 in action.

Contact us to learn more or schedule a demo.

Book a demo