← All articles

Resources

Form I-9 for Rehired Employees: New Form or Supplement B?

When a former employee comes back, HR teams often stop and ask the same question: do we start a brand-new Form I-9, or can we use the one already on file? The answer depends mostly on timing, and partly on what the old form looks like. Getting it right keeps your records clean and avoids asking a returning employee for more than the rules require.

This guide walks through how to tell a true rehire from continuing employment, when Supplement B is an option, when a new Form I-9 is the better (or only) choice, and how to apply your decision consistently.

First, confirm it is really a rehire

Not every return to work is a rehire for Form I-9 purposes. Federal guidance treats some situations as continuing employment, which means the employee never stopped being your employee and no new Form I-9 or Supplement B is needed. Examples include:

  • Approved paid or unpaid leave, such as medical or family leave
  • Promotions, demotions, transfers or pay changes within the same employer
  • Temporary layoffs for lack of work, where the employee expects to be recalled
  • Strikes or labor disputes
  • Seasonal employment, where the employee has a reasonable expectation of returning

If the person returning falls into one of these categories, keep the existing Form I-9 and carry on. The rehire decision below applies when employment actually ended and the person is now being hired again.

The three-year rule for rehires

The key date is when the employee's previous Form I-9 was completed. If you rehire someone within three years of that date, you have a choice:

  1. Complete Supplement B (Reverification and Rehires) on the existing Form I-9, or
  2. Complete a new Form I-9, just as you would for any new hire.

If the previous Form I-9 was completed more than three years ago, Supplement B is not an option for the rehire. Complete a new Form I-9.

Note that the clock runs from when the old form was completed, not from the date the employee left. Someone who worked for you for four years and left last month is outside the window, because their Form I-9 is more than three years old.

When Supplement B makes sense

Supplement B is often the faster path when the original form is recent, accurate and easy to find. To use it for a rehire, the employer:

  • Records the employee's name and the date of rehire.
  • Reviews whether the employee's work authorization, as shown on the original form, is still valid.
  • If that authorization has expired, reverifies by examining an unexpired document the employee chooses to present from List A or List C, and records it in Supplement B.
  • Signs and dates the supplement.

If the employee's name has changed since the original form, you can record the new name in Supplement B as well.

Use the current version of Supplement B, even if the original Form I-9 is an older edition. Keep the completed supplement with the original form so the records stay together. For a fuller walkthrough of the supplement itself, see our guide to Supplement B reverification and rehires.

When a new Form I-9 is the better choice

Even inside the three-year window, a new form is often the cleaner option. Consider starting fresh when:

  • You cannot locate the original Form I-9. Without the original, there is nothing to attach Supplement B to.
  • The original form has problems. If it is missing information, has errors that were never corrected, or was completed on a form version that raises questions, a new form avoids carrying those issues forward. Review your correction process with counsel before deciding what to do about the old form.
  • Your process is built around new forms. Some employers simply find it easier, and less error-prone, to have every returning employee complete a new Form I-9.

When you complete a new form, the employee completes Section 1 and chooses which acceptable documents to present for Section 2, exactly as with any new hire.

Apply the same approach to everyone

Because employers have a choice for rehires within three years, consistency matters. Choosing Supplement B for some returning employees and a new form for others, based on citizenship status, national origin or similar characteristics, can create discrimination risk. A simple written rule, such as "we always complete a new Form I-9 for rehires" or "we use Supplement B whenever the original form is within three years and on file," makes it easier for every location to follow the same path.

Whatever you choose, never ask a returning employee for specific documents. Employees decide which acceptable documents to present.

What about E-Verify?

If your company participates in E-Verify, the rehire decision affects case creation. If you complete a new Form I-9 for a rehire, you generally create a new E-Verify case for that hire. If you use Supplement B, the rules for whether to create a case depend on the situation. Check your Memorandum of Understanding and the current E-Verify user manual so your process matches the rules for your organization.

Retention for rehired employees

Rehires also affect how long you keep records. Whether you complete a new Form I-9 or use Supplement B, make sure your retention dates reflect the employee's return and any later separation, and keep the original form and its supplement together for as long as the rules require. Our guide to calculating I-9 retention dates explains the underlying rule.

A quick decision checklist

Before onboarding a returning employee, ask:

  1. Did employment actually end, or is this continuing employment?
  2. When was the previous Form I-9 completed? Is it within three years?
  3. Can we find the original form, and is it complete and accurate?
  4. Has the employee's work authorization expired since the original form?
  5. What does our written rehire policy say, so we treat this employee like everyone else?
  6. Does this rehire require a new E-Verify case?

How Clear I-9 helps

Clear I-9 by TRAK makes the rehire decision easier because your I-9 records are organized and searchable. Workflows, reporting and tracking show when an employee's previous form was completed and whether their authorization has expired, so your team can quickly see whether Supplement B is an option. Secure document imaging keeps the original form, any supplement and supporting documents together, and instant E-Verify keeps case creation in the same workflow. Built-in guidance helps completers follow the same steps every time, at every location.

Want a simpler way to handle rehires and reverification? Request a demo of Clear I-9 and we'll show you how it works.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. For guidance on your specific situation, consult qualified employment counsel and the official USCIS resources.

Book a demo

See Clear I-9 in action.

Contact us to learn more or schedule a demo.

Book a demo