← All articles

Resources

What to Do When an Employee's Work Authorization Expires

It is easy to treat Form I-9 as a one-time onboarding task. For most employees, it is. But when a new hire's work authorization has an expiration date, the Form I-9 creates an ongoing obligation: the employer must reverify that the employee is still authorized to work before that date passes.

Missed reverification dates are one of the more avoidable I-9 problems. The rules are clear, the dates are known in advance, and the fix is mostly about tracking and process. Here is what to do, and what not to do, when an employee's work authorization is about to expire.

What reverification is

Reverification is how an employer confirms that an employee whose temporary work authorization is expiring is still authorized to work in the United States. It is recorded on Supplement B of Form I-9 (formerly Section 3), which stays with the employee's original form.

Reverification is required no later than the date the employee's employment authorization expires. That date usually comes from Section 1, where the employee attests to their status, or from the work authorization document the employee presented in Section 2.

When you should not reverify

Knowing when not to reverify is just as important as knowing when to do it. Over-reverification can create discrimination risk, and the rules are specific. Do not reverify:

  • U.S. citizens or noncitizen nationals. Their work authorization does not expire.
  • Lawful permanent residents who presented a Permanent Resident Card (Form I-551) in Section 2. The card's expiration date does not mean their status has ended.
  • List B identity documents. An expired driver's license, for example, is not a reason to reverify.

Reverification is about expiring work authorization, not expiring paperwork in general. If you are unsure whether a situation calls for it, check the official USCIS guidance in the Handbook for Employers (M-274) before contacting the employee.

Build a tracking process before you need it

The single most useful thing an employer can do is track expiration dates centrally instead of relying on someone's memory or a single manager's calendar. A good tracking process:

  • Captures the work authorization expiration date when Section 1 and Section 2 are completed.
  • Generates reminders well in advance, so the employee has time to obtain new documents. Many employers start the conversation around 90 days out.
  • Escalates to HR as the date gets close if reverification has not been completed.
  • Applies the same timeline to every affected employee, every time.

Electronic I-9 systems can do much of this automatically. If you track dates in a spreadsheet, assign a clear owner and review it on a set schedule.

How to complete Supplement B

When it is time to reverify, the steps are straightforward:

  1. Notify the employee in advance that their work authorization is expiring and that they will need to present a document showing continued authorization.
  2. Let the employee choose the document. The employee may present any unexpired document from List A or List C of the Lists of Acceptable Documents. You may not ask for a specific document, and you may not require the employee to present the same type of document they showed before.
  3. Physically examine the document (or use the DHS alternative procedure if your organization qualifies and uses it consistently) and confirm it reasonably appears genuine and relates to the employee.
  4. Complete Supplement B, recording the employee's name, the document title, document number and expiration date, and the date of reverification, then sign and date it.
  5. Attach Supplement B to the employee's existing Form I-9 and retain it for as long as you retain the form.

If an employee has been reverified before, you can use an additional Supplement B page rather than starting a new Form I-9. Use the Supplement B that goes with the current edition of the form.

Automatic extensions

Sometimes an employee's work authorization document appears to have expired, but their authorization has been automatically extended. This can happen, for example, when some employees file a timely application to renew an Employment Authorization Document (EAD) in an eligible category, or when DHS extends certain documents for a designated group through a Federal Register notice.

In these situations, the employee may continue working during the extension period, and the employer should record the extension the way USCIS instructs, then reverify when the extension ends. Because the rules for automatic extensions are specific and change from time to time, check the current USCIS guidance for the employee's category rather than relying on what applied to a past employee.

What if the employee cannot present a document in time?

If the expiration date arrives and the employee has not presented an acceptable document showing continued work authorization, the employer may not knowingly continue to employ someone who is not authorized to work. How you handle the situation should follow a written policy that is applied consistently, and it is wise to involve HR leadership or counsel before taking action.

Good communication helps here. Employees who receive early, clear reminders are far more likely to have their renewed documents in hand on time, which avoids a difficult conversation for everyone.

E-Verify and reverification

If your company participates in E-Verify, note that you do not create a new E-Verify case when you reverify an existing employee. Reverification is completed on Supplement B of Form I-9. E-Verify is used for new hires, and in some cases for existing employees under specific program rules, but not as a substitute for reverification.

Avoid discrimination during reverification

Reverification touches some of the same discrimination risks as initial verification. To keep it fair:

  • Reverify only when work authorization is actually expiring, not based on an employee's appearance, accent or national origin.
  • Do not reverify early or more often than the rules require.
  • Accept any valid List A or List C document the employee chooses.
  • Treat every employee in the same situation the same way, and document what you did.

Make reverification routine

Work authorization expiration dates should never be a surprise. With dates captured at hire, reminders sent early and a simple, consistent process for completing Supplement B, reverification becomes a routine task instead of a compliance gap. Clear I-9 by TRAK tracks reverification dates, sends reminders before deadlines and guides your team through Supplement B so nothing slips past its due date.

Want reverification dates tracked for you? Request a demo of Clear I-9 and see how it works.

This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. For guidance on your specific situation, consult qualified employment counsel and the official USCIS resources.

Book a demo

See Clear I-9 in action.

Contact us to learn more or schedule a demo.

Book a demo